Blog

Sabrina told me she could be anyone.

She said it in one of our first sessions together. Her husband Tate would reach for her at night, and she would feel her whole body tense up. She had decided, somewhere along the way, that what he wanted was a body, and hers happened to be the one in the bed.

So she managed it. She said yes about as often as she thought she had to. She kept her eyes closed and waited for it to be over. And afterward she would lie there in the dark feeling like she had been used.

When I asked her what she thought Tate wanted from sex, she said, “Release. He just needs to get it out of his system.”

I asked if she had ever asked him.

She hadn’t. In eleven years of marriage, she had never once asked him the question directly. She didn’t need to. Everyone knows the answer.

The story we were handed about men

So let’s start with the answer everyone knows, because Sabrina didn’t invent it.

Men want sex for physical pleasure. They want novelty and release. They can have sex with almost anyone, in almost any emotional condition, and walk away satisfied. Women are the ones who want closeness and tenderness and to feel cherished. Men just want to get off.

We absorbed that from movies and sitcoms and jokes at wedding showers. We absorbed it from lessons that described a young man’s desire as something powerful he had to keep under control at all times. We absorbed it from books written for wives about how to keep a husband satisfied.

Most of us have never stopped to check whether any of it is accurate. That includes the women married to these men, and it includes a lot of the men themselves.

That story isn’t accurate, and I want to be precise about which part of it is wrong. The physical part is true. Men do want sex for pleasure, and there is nothing wrong with that. What isn’t true is the assumption sitting underneath it, that because he wants a body, any body would do. Let me share the research with you.

What happens when you actually ask men

Sarah Hunter Murray is a researcher and a registered marriage and family therapist who spent years studying men’s sexual desire, which almost nobody was studying. Nearly all of the research on desire had been done on women, because the working assumption in the field was that men’s desire was simple and straightforward and there was nothing underneath it worth examining.

She decided to ask men directly.

In one study, she and her colleagues interviewed thirty men between the ages of 30 and 65 who were in long-term relationships, together an average of about thirteen years, and asked them what turned their desire on and what shut it down. Fourteen themes came out of those interviews. Six of them showed up across the majority of the men, regardless of age or how long they had been together.

Three of the six brought their desire up.

1. Feeling desired by their wife.
2. Sex that felt exciting or unexpected instead of routine.
3. Being able to talk with her about things that actually mattered.

The other three shut their desire down.

1. Being turned down.
2. Physical health problems.
3. Not feeling emotionally connected to her.

I found it interesting that four of the six are about the relationship rather than the act itself.

In a later study, Murray and Lori Brotto recruited 300 men between 18 and 65 and asked how important it was to them to feel sexually desired. The vast majority said it mattered a great deal to their sexual experience. And when those men described what actually made them feel desired, much of it fell outside the script entirely. Things like romantic, non-sexual touch. Compliments. Their partner initiating.

There’s also a newer survey circulating right now, from two researchers in Vancouver, who asked hundreds of men and women why they prefer sex with a partner over sex on their own. The most common answer from both groups was emotional connection, and it ran slightly higher among the men. That study hasn’t been published or peer reviewed yet, but I thought the initial findings were fascinating. It points the same direction as work that has been published and has held up for over a decade.

However, there is older research pointing the other way. For a long time, studies found that men reported more physical reasons for sex and women reported more emotional ones. What changed in Murray’s work is the method. She asked open-ended questions instead of handing men a checklist, and she got different answers.

What Tate actually wanted

Come back to Tate for a minute.

He did what men often do and tended to hedge or hint about sex. What he didn’t do is talk about how much he wanted to connect with her.

What he would say was some version of “it’s been a while.” Sometimes “I miss you.” He would rub her back at night and stop when she didn’t respond. He always knew exactly how long it had been since the last time. And he would go quiet for three days after a “no.”

Sabrina read all of that as a man keeping score on frequency. That is a reasonable conclusion, because that is roughly what it looked like.

In a session with both of them, I asked Tate a question he had never been asked. I asked him what he wanted sex to feel like.

He sat there for a long time. Long enough that Sabrina started to fidget. Then he said, “I want to know she wants me. Not that she’s willing. That she wants me.”

Sabrina told me afterward that she cried because it had never occurred to her that he might be hoping for something she was fully capable of giving him, and that he had been waiting the whole time.

Why he never said it

So why did it take that long, and a coach asking him directly, before he could say it.

Ask a man to describe what he wants from sex and you will usually get physical vocabulary, because physical vocabulary is the only vocabulary anyone ever gave him.

Think about what a boy in our culture learns about his own desire. He learns that it’s strong. He learns that it’s a little dangerous. He learns that he is responsible for controlling it, and that a great many people are counting on him to control it. He learns to watch what he looks at and what he thinks about and how close he stands.

Nobody sits him down and tells him that underneath the urge there might be a wanting to be close to someone. To be chosen. To be let in. So he grows up able to describe the urge and unable to describe anything underneath it.

Then he gets married, and the desire he spent years controlling is suddenly supposed to be a good thing, and nobody hands him new language for it. He still has the one word. So he uses it. He says, “it’s been a while,” because that’s a sentence he knows how to make.

There’s a second thing going on. Saying “I want to feel wanted” means admitting out loud that he can be hurt by not being wanted. Many men have been taught, directly and often, that wanting something emotional from another person is weak. So the sentence stays unsaid. His wife never hears it. And the two of them settle into roles neither one picked.

I’ve had men describe feeling like a predator or pervert in their own marriage just because they desired their wife so much. Sometimes nobody has accused them of anything. Sometimes their wives have, because they were taught the same thing, that a person shouldn’t want sex that much. Either way, the only story available to them about what that wanting means is an ugly one, so they apply it to themselves.

That is a heavy thing to carry into your own bedroom.

What a “no” does

It also changes what happens when she turns him down.

Rejection came up in Murray’s research as one of the six major themes, and I think we underestimate it badly.

When a man reaches for his wife and she says “no,” we assume he is frustrated about not getting sex. Sometimes that is all it is. If what he was reaching for was reassurance that she wants him, a “no” answers a much bigger question than the one he asked out loud.

Most men won’t say any of that. Some go quiet and roll over. Some are a little short at breakfast the next morning and couldn’t tell you why. Some go the other direction and get louder, bring it up again, push. And some are genuinely just disappointed for an hour and then fine, because not every “no” lands on something tender.

What matters is whether he knows which one is happening to him. A man who has gone quiet for three days usually believes he is upset about not having sex. More often he is upset about what he decided the “no” meant.

And the silence does something to her regardless of what he intends by it. He experiences it as being hurt. She experiences it as a consequence.

Then it turns into a loop. His silence teaches her that a “no” is something that wounds him. So the next time she isn’t in the mood, she has to weigh her honest answer against three days of him being distant. Her “yes” stops being a real “yes.” He can feel she is somewhere else, which tells him she doesn’t want him. And the next time he reaches for her, it costs him more to do it.

Both of them are managing each other now. They are both working from bad information.

Kendra was being generous

I want to tell you about another couple.

Kendra and Warren had been married nine years, and she had made her peace with the arrangement. Warren wanted sex more often than she did. Kendra decided the kindest thing she could do was make it easy for him.

So she said yes. She kept it short and efficient and she never complained about it. She genuinely thought of it as generosity, and in her own accounting she was being a very good wife.

Warren experienced it as being handled.

He told me he knew every single time. That she was being nice to him. That she was waiting for it to be over. She thought she was doing a decent job of hiding it, but he could tell. He said the physical part was fine and the whole thing left him feeling worse than if they had just gone to sleep.

Kendra was floored. She had spent all that time handing him exactly what she believed he wanted, and the thing she thought she was giving was not the thing he was there for. She was generously giving him the wrong thing.

Being tolerated in bed is lonely. A man can get the sex and still walk away feeling like he took something. And once he has felt that enough times, he stops being able to enjoy a “yes” even when it is real.

Closeness by itself doesn’t fix this

Before I go further, I need to complicate this.

Emotional closeness does not automatically produce desire.

There’s research going back more than a decade on emotional intimacy and men’s sexuality, and it found what you’d expect, that emotional closeness generally supports desire and satisfaction. That same work looked at a complication. When closeness tips over into emotional fusion, desire can drop off.

Emotional fusion is a term out of Murray Bowen’s family systems work, and Dr. David Schnarch, who wrote Passionate Marriage, built much of his thinking about marriage and sex around it. It means the two of you have blended so completely that there is not much of a separate person left on either side. You share every opinion. Neither one of you can be in a bad mood without the other one catching it. There isn’t much of a thought or a plan or a preference that isn’t joint.

And most of the time we think we are doing exactly the right thing. We are being one. That is the language we were raised on about what a good marriage looks like, so we go after it, and the closer we get to it the better we think we are doing.

The trouble is that desire requires another person to want. That sounds like it couldn’t possibly be the problem, because of course there is another person, right there in the bed.

But the separateness that matters here isn’t physical. It is whether there is a self over there that you haven’t already absorbed into your own. Opinions you can’t predict. Moods that aren’t a 44reflection of yours. An inner life you don’t have full access to. When all of that has blended together, you can be lying next to someone and still have nobody to reach for.

And this runs in both directions. Fusion doesn’t only flatten his desire for her. It flattens hers for him just as much, and often sooner.

Feeling safe with someone and being fused with them are two different things.

So more connection is not the whole answer here. There are couples who are already very close and still have flat, boring sex, and telling them to get closer would make it worse. What they are short on is separateness.

None of that changes what this episode is actually about. If you have been operating for years on the belief that your husband wants a body and doesn’t particularly care whose, that belief is costing you something, and there’s a good chance it isn’t true. That was Sabrina’s belief the whole time.

What feeling desired actually looks like

Feeling wanted stays vague until you get specific about what it actually looks like day to day.

The men in Murray’s research were specific about this, and almost none of what they named was about performance.

Things like romantic, non-sexual touch. Her hand on his back walking past him in the kitchen. A hug that lasts longer than two seconds. Being touched at a moment when it obviously isn’t going anywhere.

Compliments. Being told he’s attractive out loud, by his wife, in words. Many of these men said the last time anyone told them that was years ago.

Initiating. Being pursued instead of always being the one doing the pursuing. Having the roles reverse sometimes.

And this one mattered as much as any of them: her being present during sex. Actually in the room, in her own body, interested in what is happening. The men in that study were clear that they had no interest in sex with someone who was waiting for it to end.

Notice that the majority of that list happens outside of sex entirely, and none of it requires you to want sex more often than you do.

The physical part is real

None of that means the physical stopped mattering to him.

Your husband probably does want sex for physical reasons. He likes how it feels. He likes how you look. He wants your body, and he thinks about it more often than you would guess. None of that is a character flaw, and none of it is something he is supposed to grow out of.

The question was never whether the physical matters to him. The question is whether you specifically matter to him. Most of us have collapsed those into one question, and they are not the same.

He wants to be physical with you. Not with a body. With yours, because it is yours, because he chose you and he still wants you. And for a lot of men, that is the clearest way they know how to say I love you. He may not have words for what he feels about you at the end of a hard week. He does have his hands.

Can he learn to do more than that? Yes. He can learn to say it in words. He can learn to see you as a whole person and not only as the person he goes to bed with. That is real work and it is worth him doing.

But the reaching itself was never the problem.

For the wife who has been assuming

So let me talk to the wives for a minute.

You don’t have to manufacture desire you don’t feel in order to start here.

Most women experience desire responsively, which means it shows up after the connection starts instead of before it. You can’t force the front end of that, and I’m not asking you to.

What you can do is stop answering a question you never asked him.

Ask him what he wants sex to feel like when it’s good, and what it feels like when it isn’t. Then let it be awkward, because it will be, and do not fill the silence for him. He may need a minute. He has very likely never been asked this in his life.

When he tells you, believe him. If he says he wants to feel wanted, resist the urge to translate that back into something more familiar. We are very good at hearing what we already expected to hear.

And if what he tells you is different from what you assumed, there is work to do on your part.

Own what you believed about him. You decided at some point that he wanted a body and didn’t much care whose, and then you ran your marriage on that.

Own how you showed up because of it. The going along with it. The checking out. The waiting for it to be over.

Own that you probably picked this belief up somewhere long before you ever met him, that you never once examined it, and that it turned out to be wrong.

And then do something different.

For the husband who has never said it

Husbands, your turn.

Your wife is not a mind reader, and the signals you have been sending have been almost entirely about frequency.

“It’s been a while” is not a good way to initiate. “I miss you” is closer. “I want to feel like you want me, not like you’re being generous” is what you actually mean, and I know exactly what it costs to say it.

Tell her you want to feel wanted, and do it outside the bedroom, at a time when nothing is on the line and nobody is about to be turned down. Say it when you are not asking for anything at all. That’s the only condition under which she can hear it as information instead of pressure.

Be honest with yourself first, because plenty of men don’t actually know the answer. If wanting sex is the only way you have ever described this to yourself, give it a few days before you try to talk about it. What are you actually reaching for at eleven o’clock at night? Is it release? Is it reassurance? Is it that you haven’t felt like she’s on your team in about six weeks and sex is the only way you know how to bring it up?

Whatever it is, she can’t respond to it until you say it.

He can’t get all of it from her

Saying it out loud is the first half. The second half is harder.

A man can hear this episode and decide his job is to wait for his wife to make him feel desirable. That she owes him that, and that until she comes through, he is justified in feeling how he feels.

That doesn’t work, for two reasons.

The first is that it puts his sense of himself in her hands. If he only feels like a man worth wanting when she initiates, his worth runs on a schedule he does not control, and every ordinary dry spell turns into evidence about who he is. No wife can carry that. She will feel the weight of it, and she will start managing him the way Sabrina was managing Tate, and now the same problem is running in the other direction.

The second is that desire on demand is not desire. The reason Warren felt hollow after sex with Kendra was that she was doing it because she was supposed to. If he now expects her to produce wanting on schedule, he has asked her for the exact thing that made him feel terrible in the first place.

So there is a second question for husbands, and it is harder than the first one. Do you believe you are desirable? And are you acting like it?

I don’t mean performing for her. I mean looking honestly at what you are bringing. Are you someone she would want to be close to this week? Are you pursuing her as a person and not only as access to sex? Are you pleasant to live with? Are you still growing, or did you stop about six years ago and start waiting for her to notice you?

A man who has sat with those questions can tell his wife he wants to feel wanted without it sounding like a demand. He can want it and still be steady when he doesn’t get it. That is the version she can actually respond to, because it isn’t asking her to hold him up.

Sabrina and Tate

Sabrina and Tate didn’t fix this in a conversation.

What shifted first was Sabrina’s story about what was happening. She stopped reading his hand on her back as a demand. That alone took a few months, because a belief that old does not dissolve the moment you learn something new about it.

Then she started reaching for him, and at first it had nothing to do with sex. She’d come up behind him at the sink. She’d kiss him for longer than the two seconds they had defaulted to. She told me that the first time she initiated sex, he stopped and asked if she was sure.

Tate had work to do too, and I want to be clear that this wasn’t a project where Sabrina fixed it. He had to stop going quiet for three days after a “no,” because that silence had been teaching his wife for years that her honest answer was a wound. And he had to say the actual sentence out loud more than once. He wanted to say it a single time and be finished with it, and that is not how it works.

The sex got better. The part Sabrina told me surprised her most was that once she stopped believing she was interchangeable, she could pay attention to her own pleasure for the first time in years.

Where this leaves us

That was available to her the whole time. She just didn’t know to look for it.

God gave us bodies and God gave us the capacity to be known by another person, and I don’t believe those two things were meant to run on separate tracks inside a marriage.

When we teach men that their sexuality is only appetite, we are telling them something untrue about how they were made, and many of them believe it about themselves. When women believe it, they stop looking for what else he might want. Everybody loses something.

Your husband might be one of the men for whom the physical really is the loudest part. That’s real too, and I’m not trying to talk you out of what you know about your own marriage. But you cannot know until you ask, and most of us have never asked.

So ask.

A membership for men

Before I give you the questions, I want to say something directly to the men listening.

I’m considering opening a membership just for you. It would include the monthly classes from my class library, 20-minute semi-private coaching sessions with me, and a group coaching call once a month.

Before I build anything, I want to know if you would use it. I’ll put the link to the interest form in the show notes. This doesn’t commit you to anything, it just lets me know if there is enough interest for me to build this.

And if you’re a wife listening and you think your husband might be interested, send him the link.

https://airtable.com/appAch4uB19x84ZKZ/paggqDY8FxrLKaFgM/form